Save the Scenic Santa Ritas

Fighting to protect the Santa Rita and Patagonia Mountains from the devastating impacts of mining.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Contact
    • Board of Directors and Staff
    • Endorsements
    • Opposition and Resolutions
    • Volunteers and Friends
  • Background
    • Rosemont Mine
      • History
      • Impacts
        • Air Quality
        • Land Use
        • Wildlife and Habitat
        • Scenic Views
        • Heritage
        • Recreation
        • Economy
        • Water and Hydrology
    • Legislation
    • Copper
    • Patagonia Area Mines
  • In the News
  • Action
    • What Can I Do?
    • Donate
    • Volunteer
    • Join Mailing List
    • Endorse Us
    • SSSR Presentation
    • Show Your Support
    • Letter Writing
  • Events
    • Past Events
  • Resources
    • Recommended Reading
    • Visual Media
    • Links
    • Documents and Reports
    • 1872 Mining Law
    • Inspiration
  • Projects
    • Lens on the Land
      • Biodiversity
      • Culture
      • Economy: Industry, Tourism & Recreation
      • The Land
      • Night Sky and Astronomy
      • Water Resources
    • Rosemont Mine Truth
  • Newsletter

Letters to the Editor

September 24, 2010 By Administrator Leave a Comment


Compromise is not a solution to proposed Rosemont Mine

Published on Saturday, September 25, 2010, Inside Tucson Business

TO: The Editor

FROM: Leslie Kramer, former President, Sonoita Chamber of Commerce

Nancy McCoy, former president, Patagonia Area Business Association

RE: “Rosemont Mine fight is all about ranting and not about problem solving,” Hugh Holub opinion, Sept. 6 issue

As members of the business community of Sonoita, Patagonia, and Elgin, we understand

of course, that the Rosemont Copper Company owns land in the Santa Rita Mountains. They own 900+ acres and if they were planning to limit their open pit mine to that property, they would have every right to do so. However, their proposal is to use nearly 4,000 acres of public land in the Coronado National Forest on which they want to dump waste piles that would be upwards of 30 stories high and would spread over several square miles. The piles would essentially fill the valley and destroy it forever.

The Rosemont Valley is a popular place. On virtually every weekend it is visited by campers, picnickers, hikers, bicyclists and ATV riders. It is much used, in season, by hunters. It is also the location of about 100 prehistoric sites. If the Rosemont copper project is allowed to proceed, this valley and its natural and cultural landscape will literally be buried under thousands of tons of waste rock.

We also want to point out that the economies of Sonoita, Elgin and Patagonia are based on ranching, wineries and a variety of businesses relating to recreation and tourism such as restaurants, B&B’s and specialty shops. The only way to reach our area from Tucson and Phoenix is to drive down Arizona Highway 83, a beautiful, two-lane state scenic route. We are very concerned about the many negative impacts this proposed mine would have: air pollution, traffic congestion and safety, depressed real estate values and a just plain ugly view – to name a few.

As to water use, of course there are other water users in the Upper Santa Cruz Valley. There are communities like Green Valley and Sahuarita, agricultural users and existing mines on the west side. However, Rosemont would be a NEW user. The company wants to pump groundwater from an already depleted water table. Unfortunately, it has the right to do so because mining is the only enterprise exempt from state law regulating groundwater withdrawals. Yes, a permit is required, but it is a “non-discretionary” permit. This means that the state does not have the right to say “no.” So, in the future, if Rosemont’s proposed “dry tailings” method does not work, it will be able to drill more and deeper wells, lowering the water table even farther.

With respect to the issue of Central Arizona Project (CAP) water, it is certainly true that much better use should be made of Rosemont’s current allocation. Rosemont dumps their CAP allocation north of Marana, a practice that has no benefit for the greater Tucson area. What is the availability of CAP water as drought continues and demand for CAP water increases? Many CAP users – municipalities, for example – have a higher priority than Rosemont. There is simply no guarantee that the Green Valley area will ever be adequately compensated for the removal of 6000 – 8000 acre feet per year of valuable ground water. That is enough water to supply the residential needs of 32,000 people. This kind of pumping is a huge risk that must be borne by both present and future residential, agricultural and commercial users.

As to the tailings piles being visible from Green Valley: They will not be visible. However, Gil Clausen, president of Rosemont’s parent company, noted in World Mining Stocks (September 2007) that “although developing Rosemont was clearly the company’s primary focus, the three other properties (on the Santa Rita ridgeline and on the west slope of the mountains) offered future opportunities for exploration.” Thus, if Rosemont is approved for the east side of the Santa Ritas, it is certainly possible that the mining operation could be expanded over the ridge to the west. If that occurs, massive tailings would indeed be visible from Green Valley.

Finally, although compromise and negotiation are frequently productive ways to resolve difficult issues, they are not the solution in this case. Mr. Holub’s assertion that Rosemont should buy some other environmentally sensitive land and donate it to Pima County does nothing to offset the negative impacts of this proposed mine. Nor does this proposed solution do anything for all that will be affected by the proposed mine in Santa Cruz County.

It is important to remember that the proposed Rosemont mine is very unpopular. It is opposed by virtually every jurisdiction in this part of the state including Pima and Santa Cruz Counties, the City of Tucson, the Tohono O’odham Nation, numerous legislators and Congresswoman Gabriel Giffords and Congressman Raul Grijalva. Thousands of individuals have signed petitions opposing the mine.

The solution to this problem is not some kind of “negotiated” settlement. Rosemont Copper must not be allowed to mine in the Santa Rita Mountains. The future of our community, our economy, our clean air, and our water depends on this decision.

Copyright © 2010 Inside Tucson Business

 


 

The Truth About Copper

Submitted by Marshall Magruder, June 28th, 2010 to the Arizona Daily Star

Dear Editor,

You article, “Rosemont stressing copper’s greenness” included a Rosemont Copper flier “How Rosemont Fits into the Green Economy.”  There are some corrections to Rosemont Copper’s position that need to be made.  

Rosemont says: “New transmission lines for renewable energy will require millions of tons of copper.” Transmission lines today use NO COPPER. Aluminum is used because it is lighter—requiring fewer poles, stronger because steel-reinforced, and cheaper. Aluminum, not copper, is most commonly used in powerlines to customers and in their homes and buildings.

Rosemont Copper’s line about “millions of tons of copper” is also a gross overstatement. According to the Copper Development Association, the total 2009 US copper production was 1,299,000 tons, much less than the “millions of tons.” Any new mine would not produce anywhere near “millions of tons,” nor is that much needed.

Further, the statement about solar photovoltaic panels, such as the girl in the ad is holding, is also misleading. Silicon is the primary resource in photovoltaic panels. The frames are aluminum.  Very little copper is used.

Turbines in coal, gas, and nuclear power plants are made of steel, not copper. The electric generators usually have copper wire around iron or steel magnetic material. This is true for any power source.

Let’s avoid false and erroneous statements. Rosemont Copper should retract their misleading, to say the least, statements.

Please see the Standard Handbook for Electrical Engineers to verify that transmission; distribution and feeder lines and solar panels do NOT use copper.

Filed Under: Letters

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Recent Posts

  • Federal Memo May Bolster Hudbay’s Position on Rosemont Mine Site March 16, 2023
  • Hudbay Minerals Stock Tumbled 16% Last Week to US$4.55 per Share March 16, 2023
  • Hudbay Fights Order to Stop Grading at Mine Site Near Tucson March 16, 2023
  • THE HOT TOPIC: WATER OR LACK THEREOF January 24, 2023
  • Hudbay ramps up excavation for Copper World Complex as local resistance continues and expands January 7, 2023
  • Meet The Man Who Shoots At Birds All Day To Keep Them Off A Toxic Pit | World Wide Waste (video) January 5, 2023
  • Lithium America Mine Project Hampered After Judge Schedules Hearing on Nevada Mine January 5, 2023
  • Thousands Will Live Here One Day (as Long as They Can Find Water) January 5, 2023
  • Latest Updates About Local Water Issues and Rosemont / Copper World Mine Complex January 5, 2023
  • Hudbay, Forest Service won’t appeal ruling blocking Rosemont Mine December 19, 2022

Newsletter Sign-up

Sign up to receive important updates straight to your inbox! We will guard your privacy and will not provide your email to anyone else.

Rosemont/ Copper World Mine Complex News

Federal Memo May Bolster Hudbay’s Position on Rosemont Mine Site

Hudbay Fights Order to Stop Grading at Mine Site Near Tucson

THE HOT TOPIC: WATER OR LACK THEREOF

Hudbay ramps up excavation for Copper World Complex as local resistance continues and expands

Meet The Man Who Shoots At Birds All Day To Keep Them Off A Toxic Pit | World Wide Waste (video)

Lithium America Mine Project Hampered After Judge Schedules Hearing on Nevada Mine

More Posts from this Category

Hudbay Minerals Stock Tumbled 16% Last Week to US$4.55 per Share

 

Update on Lake Mead and Lake Powell water levels

All that rain and snow hammering the West surely means good news for water levels in Lake Mead and Lake Powell. Here’s a video update from last week with the current situation and expectations for the rest of the year.
WATCH NOW

Copper World Flyover January 6, 2023 by David Steele

Another shocking sight of the incredible destruction happening on our beautiful Santa Ritas.WATCH VIDEO NOW

Russ McSpadden’s recent fly-over showing mine activity

In Nov 2022 Russ captured recent bulldozing in the Santa Rita Mountains. His video starts over the Rosemont mine project on the east side and then swings over the Copper World project on the west side. WATCH VIDEO NOW

Explore the proposed Rosemont and Copper World projects virtually

Check out Pima County’s updated map of the proposed mine site. Click on any spot on the map for ownership/status information. Mapping details are based on Hudbay’s PEA dated May 1.

Proposed Rosemont/ Copper World Mine Complex

Image compilation of the area

LENS ON THE LAND

Recommended Reading List

Browse HERE over 30 titles of carefully selected books in various categories including: copper, water, mining, wilderness, exploration, and more. Your purchase supports the efforts of the SSSR

January 2023 Powerpoint Presentation

Click here to download (PDF)

Litigation Update

There have been two recent judicial rulings on the Rosemont Copper Company projects — one favorable and one unfavorable.

Click here to learn more

The latest on Hudbay’s Copper World project in the Santa Rita Mountains

Click here to download (PDF)

Where is the Rosemont/Copper World Mine Complex?

Click here for directions

HELP US PROTECT THE SANTA RITAS

DONATE

Copyright © 2023 · Save the Scenic Santa Ritas